In this paper i critically examine brian leftows attempt to construct a theistic semantics for counterpossibles, one that can be used to make sense of the. God and necessity the philosophical quarterly oxford. Fortunately, brian leftow has a welldeveloped proposal on offer here. Bibliographies for theology, compiled by william harmless, s. He adopts a mixed voluntaristmentalist account in it. Philosophical society with the support of biola university as a vehicle for the scholarly discussion of philosophy and philosophical issues in the fields of apologetics, ethics, theology, and religion. This book offers a theory of the possible and the necessary modality in which god plays the chief role, and a new sort of argument for gods existence. Brian leftow, a timeless god incarnate in stephen t.
The volume is essentially the first quarter or so of part one of summa theologiae, where aquinas addressed the topic of the existence and nature of god. Worlds and the existence of god oxford scholarship. For all x, if x is not god, a part, aspect or attribute of god or an event, god makes the creating ex nihilo sort of causal contribution to xs existence as long as x exists. This chapter offers an argument intended to appeal to some atheists.
God has the gsa god is the source of all property, for instance. Review of brian leftows god and necessity sam cowling, denison university penultimate draft. Anselm on the necessity of the incarnation cambridge core. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise cambridge.
Leftows god and necessity is a remarkable achievement, a major contribution to modal metaphysics, striking in its creativity, impressive in its argumentation, and mindnumbing in its. Most analytic philosophers hold that if god exists, he exists with broad logical necessity. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. But it is a voluntaristmentalist account of modality rather than grounding of abstract objects. God and necessity books pics download new books and. For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing. Leftows god and necessity is a remarkable achievement, a major contribution to modal metaphysics, striking in its creativity, impressive in its argumentation, and mindnumbing in its thoroughness. Buy god and necessity reprint by leftow, brian isbn.
Metaphysical necessity is contrasted with other types of necessity. God and necessity aims to draw out the metaphysical implications of a particularly demanding view of divine ultimacy. This book offers a theory of the possible and the necessary modality in which god plays the chief role, and a. In god and necessity brian leftow provides an original explanation of kinds and essences in terms of freely chosen divine powers, which act as substitutes for possible worlds. I show that features of anselms concept of god and treatment of necessity make the claim that the incarnation is a necessary means of salvation problematic. Brian leftow 2014 european journal for philosophy of religion 6 3. An interdisciplinary symposium on the incarnation of the son of god oxford. Davis, daniel kendall sj, gerald ocollins sj eds, the incarnation. It is not clear to me whether anselm concludes that fallen angels cannot be saved, or implies only that if fallen angels can be saved, it must be done in some other way. Brian leftow offers a theist theory of necessity and possibility, and a new sort of argument for gods existence. Brian leftow s 2012 god and necessity is an important recent book in philosophical theology.
Metaphysical necessity has proved a controversial concept, and criticized by david hume, immanuel kant, j. He argues that necessities of logic and mathematics are determined by god s nature, but that it is events in god s mind his imagination and choice that account for necessary truths about concrete creatures. It has become usual to say that a proposition is possible just in case it is true in some. This is the part of the book where aquinas is approaching the question from. Pdf god of the possible download full pdf book download. Reading the book is somewhat reminiscent of ploughing ones way through aquinas summa contra gentiles. Modal basics some solutions theist solutions the ontology of.
Please read our short guide how to send a book to kindle. Jun 25, 2015 leftow anticipates and forestalls many likely objections to his claims. God is the greatest possible being, but on the claim that god is the greatest conceivable being. Download pdf godofthepossible free online new books in. God and other necessary beings stanford encyclopedia of. The best books on the existence of god ed feser on five. Mar 01, 2015 read brian leftow, god and necessity oxford. Review of brian leftow s god and necessity sam cowling, denison university penultimate draft. Brian leftow offers a theist theory of necessity and possibility, and a new sort of argument for god s existence. So far, the book has offered arguments for its theory intended to appeal to theists, recommending the books view against rival theist theories.
Brian leftow a leibnizian cosmological argument received 19 may, 1988. Philosophia christi 12 evangelical philosophical society. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library. Intext references and unattributed references below are to this paper.
Brian leftow has likewise allowed that, for anselm, gods perfect wisdom could craft and omnipotence execute a plan of salvation not involving an incarnation, with the consequence that the incarnation is necessary only relative to other, contingent divine decisions. For example, the philosophers of religion john hick and william l. In god and necessity, brian leftow issues a major challenge to modal realists, theists or not, by defending a metaphysics of modality in which god is boss. Brian leftow on one person christology right reason. Review of brian leftow, god and necessity springerlink. Your first book is summa theologiae, questions on god edited by brian davies and brian leftow. In 1974 alvin plantingas the nature of necessity signaled a renaissance of christian philosophy in the anglophone world. Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following locations. Brian leftow a leibnizian cosmological argument received 19 may, 1988 contemporary philosophers frequently claim that the truthconditions of modal claims involve necessarily existing abstract entities, be they states of affairs, propositions, attributes or possible worlds. Apologetics southwestern baptist theological seminary. It is also true that god is not only the source of existences but also that of essences insofar as they are real, that is, the source of that which is real in possibility. Historically, theistic metaphysics mostly answered yes. Leftow s main case for his theory is that it explains what needs to be explained and is superior to rival candidate metaphysics of absolute necessity and possibility from now on, necessity, necessarily and necessary will always signify absolute necessity. The best books on the existence of god ed feser on five books.
Brian leftow offers a theory of the possible and the necessary in which god plays the chief role, and a new sort of argument for god s existence. Brian leftows new book god and necessity epitomizes that renaissance. William lane craig, naturalism and intelligent design, in intelligent design, ed. Brian leftow, anselm on the necessity of the incarnation, religious studies 31 1995. Nov 18, 20 leftow offers a series of principles that characterize his conception of divine ultimacy. God and necessity by brian leftow 2012 1108 brian leftow. God and necessity brian leftow oxford university press. Leftow anticipates and forestalls many likely objections to his claims. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view download pdf for offline viewing. Leftows main case for his theory is that it explains what needs to be explained and is superior to rival candidate metaphysics of absolute necessity and possibility from now on, necessity, necessarily and necessary will always signify absolute necessity. It contends by appeal to ockhams razor and other considerations that the books theory is preferable to belief in possible worlds. God and other necessary beings notes stanford encyclopedia. It is a major contribution to modal metaphysics, striking in its creativity, impressive in its.
Brian leftow offers a theory of the possible and the necessary in which god plays the chief role, and a new sort of argument for gods existence. Leftow is also credited for proposing an explanation about the constant change in god prior to creation that god can delay creating to enjoy anticipating a universe and or desiring to create one. Oct 24, 2008 11 i show below that anselms arguments for the necessity of the incarnation obey this stricture. Swinburne on divine necessity cambridge university press. Western monotheism teaches that everything nondivine traces back in some way to god. God and necessity the philosophical quarterly oxford academic. He argues that necessities of logic and mathematics are determined by gods nature, but that it is events in gods mind his imagination and choice that account for necessary truths about concrete creatures. God and counterpossibles richard brian davis faculty of philosophy, tyndale university college, toronto, canada, m2m 4b3 abstract. The books topic is the challenge that necessary truths pose for the claim that god is the sole ultimate reality. This is because gods understanding is the realm of eternal truths, or that of the ideas on which they depend. Materialism and christian belief alvin plantinga according to materialism, human persons are material objects.
Brian leftow is currently considered a single author. He argues that necessities of logic and mathematics are determined by gods nature, but that it is events in gods mind his imagination and choice. Leftow offered a reply on behalf of the perfect being theologian. Brian leftows 2012 god and necessity is an important recent book in philosophical theology. It is a work that takes seriously the reality and supremacy of god in all things and. Clarendon press, 1994 against criticisms made by among others brian leftow in a paper swinburne on divine necessity, religious studies, 46 2010, 141162. If one or more works are by a distinct, homonymous authors, go ahead and split the author. Download pdf godofthepossible free online new books. It has become usual to say that a proposition is possible just in case it is true in some possible world roughly, some complete history a universe might have and. Necessary and other modal truths raises a question for this. It has become usual to say that a proposition is possible just in case it is true in some possible world roughly, some complete history a universe might have and necessary just if it is true in all. How creation accounts for divine action in the world.
315 129 63 874 648 1245 1389 1093 730 667 586 641 1300 527 1242 831 1092 618 72 744 625 162 696 203 920 526 840 823 1431 286 1492 85 823